This is a sample report for a fictional organisation (Fictional insurer). Your report is written from your own answers.
Take the assessmentAI Readiness Assessment
Sample report: AI Readiness Assessment
Completed 21 November 2026
Overall score
Emerging
The organisation is currently automating chaos rather than streamlining value, creating significant operational debt by scaling AI before achieving process maturity.
Scorecard
Your score by area
Each area is scored from your answers. A weakness in one area holds back the others.
Red flags
Answers that need urgent attention (3)
These answers sit at the weakest level.
Executive summary
What this means for your organisation
The organisation is in a fragile state where AI initiatives are driven by vendor hype and internal enthusiasm rather than strategic business requirements. With an overall maturity score of 35 percent, the current approach of automating existing, undocumented processes is likely to accelerate inefficiencies and introduce systemic risks into back-office insurance workflows. The lack of a unified business case for AI investment leaves the firm vulnerable to fragmented, unscalable experiments that fail to deliver measurable ROI.
Your core diagnosis reveals that the fundamental discipline of process engineering is missing. By failing to standardise and improve processes before automation, the organisation is merely digitising manual workarounds. This 'pave the cow path' strategy is compounded by a lack of internal governance, meaning that sensitive insurance data is being managed without clear rules, and AI-driven decisions currently lack the transparency required for regulatory compliance in the insurance sector.
To move forward, the leadership must pivot from a technology-first mindset to a process-first foundation. The immediate priority is to halt the uncoordinated rollout of AI tools and establish a robust process management framework. Success requires treating AI as an amplifier of stable, documented, and measured operations. You must shift ownership from IT and technology enthusiasts to business process owners and integrate rigorous performance measurement as a prerequisite for any further automation.
Key strengths
- Business owners are identified for key data sets, providing a foundation for accountability.
- Staff are already comfortable using approved AI tools for everyday productivity tasks.
- A standard, though not always followed, way of working exists for core processes.
- A culture of human oversight for critical decisions and customer contact is already embedded.
Risk register
Critical risks
Ranked by severity, with the business consequence and the recommended mitigation.
Regulatory non-compliance due to lack of explainability in AI-supported decisions.
Impact
Severe regulatory penalties and loss of customer trust in an insurance context.
Mitigation
Cease deployment of black-box AI tools for critical decisions until model interpretability can be documented.
Operational instability from automating inconsistent and undocumented processes.
Impact
Increased error rates and unpredictability in back-office service delivery.
Mitigation
Mandate process mapping and standardisation before any automation initiative is funded.
Wasted investment due to project-by-project funding without clear business cases.
Impact
Financial loss and inability to demonstrate value to the board.
Mitigation
Establish an AI steering committee to approve funding only for projects with defined ROI targets.
Data privacy breaches stemming from informal handling of sensitive information in AI tools.
Impact
Data leakage and potential breach of insurance data protection standards.
Mitigation
Develop and enforce a strict data handling policy for all AI-enabled platforms.
Dependencies
How the areas affect each other
- Weak process foundations mean that AI tools are being applied to unstable workflows, causing performance gains to be cancelled out by manual workarounds.
- The lack of strategic alignment in selecting use cases prevents the conversion of pilots into business value, as projects are driven by vendor hype rather than organisational objectives.
Benchmark
Maturity benchmark
Maturity for each area on a five-level scale, compared with typical organisations.
Level 2, Emerging. Typical insurers at this stage have a formalised digital transformation office, whereas this organisation remains reactive.
Level 1, Ad hoc. Leading operations teams mandate process redesign before any technology deployment.
Level 2, Emerging. Mature organisations treat data as an asset with automated extraction and high-quality pipelines.
Level 2, Emerging. Leading organisations have formal AI academies and change management programmes.
Level 2, Emerging. Regulated firms typically require robust, documented guardrails and model validation frameworks.
Level 1, Ad hoc. Successful firms focus on a small number of high-value use cases that scale rapidly.
Momentum
Quick wins
Actions you can take in the next two to four weeks.
Form an AI steering committee with business and IT leadership.
Head of Operations · 2 weeks
Ensures business alignment for all future AI investment.
Draft and socialise a clear AI acceptable use policy.
Chief Risk Officer · 3 weeks
Mitigates immediate data handling and security risks.
Inventory current AI pilots and force a stop-go decision based on business case.
Operations Manager · 4 weeks
Eliminates resource drain on low-value experiments.
Implement a standard template for documenting the five most critical back-office processes.
Process Owner · 4 weeks
Provides baseline documentation for future automation.
Diagnosis
Area-by-area diagnosis
01Strategy and leadership
Strategy is currently fragmented with little business involvement in sponsorship. Vendors hold too much influence over project selection. Funding lacks a clear business case and is tied to individual projects rather than strategic outcomes. The organisation is failing to treat AI as a core capability.
Root causes
- • Absence of a centralised AI steering committee
- • Over-reliance on external vendor advice for strategic direction
Evidence from your answers
“IT or one enthusiast drives it, with little business involvement”
“Funding comes project by project, with no clear business case”
Strengths
- • AI goals exist for some business areas
Gaps
- • No clear link between AI investment and measurable business outcomes
- • Business managers are not taking ownership of AI initiatives
Actions
- • Establish an AI steering committee involving both business and IT leaders.
- • Implement a standard project appraisal process for all new AI initiatives.
- • Shift the budget model from project-based to outcomes-based funding.
02Process foundations
Processes are currently undocumented or inconsistent. The reliance on workarounds makes them unsuitable for automation. Automation is being applied to the status quo without simplification. Measurement is inconsistent, preventing a true understanding of current performance.
Root causes
- • Lack of formalised process management standards
- • Preference for rapid technology deployment over process rigour
Evidence from your answers
“It is automated as it is”
“There is a standard way, but workarounds are common”
Strengths
- • Recognition that standard processes should exist
Gaps
- • No standardisation of work prior to automation
- • Inconsistent performance measurement
Actions
- • Mandate process documentation for all areas slated for AI adoption.
- • Remove workarounds by redesigning the process for efficiency before automation.
- • Implement a consistent reporting framework for all core processes.
03Data readiness
Data accessibility is constrained by manual effort. Quality issues are only caught reactively. There is no clear rule for handling sensitive data within AI tools despite having named owners for datasets.
Root causes
- • Lack of automated data integration pipelines
- • Reactive rather than proactive data quality management
Evidence from your answers
“Available, but getting it takes manual effort and IT requests”
“Issues are found and fixed when reports look wrong”
Strengths
- • Business owners are named for key data sets
Gaps
- • Manual effort required for data access
- • Lack of clear governance for sensitive data in AI tools
Actions
- • Develop an automated data access policy for business teams.
- • Formalise data quality checks at the point of entry.
- • Publish clear, enforceable rules for data security in AI applications.
04People and skills
Training is currently informal and self-directed. The lack of open discussion about AI's impact on roles creates uncertainty. A few isolated individuals are attempting to bridge the gap between AI and process, but they lack organisational support.
Root causes
- • Lack of structured change management for AI adoption
- • Absence of a formalised AI competency programme
Evidence from your answers
“Informal tips and self-directed learning”
“Mixed feelings that are rarely discussed openly”
Strengths
- • Many staff already use approved tools for everyday tasks
Gaps
- • Informal and ad hoc training
- • Lack of open communication channels regarding job changes
Actions
- • Launch an AI training programme tailored to different business roles.
- • Create an open forum for staff to voice concerns regarding AI adoption.
- • Formalise the role of process-AI bridge individuals within the organisation.
05Governance, risk and ethics
Governance is informal, with risk management only occurring after an incident. A significant failure point is the inability to explain AI-supported decisions, which is critical for insurance. Reliance on human review is a temporary safeguard that does not replace systemic governance.
Root causes
- • Lack of AI-specific risk management framework
- • Absence of model interpretability requirements
Evidence from your answers
“No, we cannot explain how AI-supported decisions are made”
“Risks are discussed when something goes wrong”
Strengths
- • Human-in-the-loop review process is established
Gaps
- • No ability to explain AI decisions
- • Risk management is entirely reactive
Actions
- • Develop a formal AI governance framework and ethics policy.
- • Require explainability as a gate for any AI project adoption.
- • Implement a proactive AI risk register.
06Use cases and value
Pilots rarely move into production. Value is measured by anecdote rather than hard data. There is no process to transition experiments into operations, leaving the firm with a graveyard of pilots and no tangible return on investment.
Root causes
- • Absence of a formalised innovation-to-production pipeline
- • Failure to define success metrics at the outset of pilots
Evidence from your answers
“Pilots rarely finish or scale”
“By anecdote or user feedback only”
Strengths
- • Willingness to experiment with new AI tools
Gaps
- • No measurable results from AI pilots
- • Failure to scale pilots to everyday operations
Actions
- • Define success metrics for every new pilot before launch.
- • Create a formal process for transitioning successful pilots to production.
- • Conduct a review of all current pilots and retire those without clear ROI.
Measures
KPIs to track
Measures that show whether things are improving.
Process standardisation rate
Process foundationsMeasures the extent to which staff are following documented procedures vs. workarounds.
Target: Increase to 90% in 12 months.
Time to resolve AI-supported process issues
Governance, risk and ethicsTracks the ability to manage and explain errors in AI outputs.
Target: Reduce by 50% in 6 months.
AI pilot to production conversion rate
Use cases and valueIndicates the effectiveness of the innovation pipeline.
Target: 30% within 9 months.
Percentage of AI decisions fully explainable
Governance, risk and ethicsCritical compliance metric for insurance operations.
Target: 100% for all customer-facing models in 12 months.
Data accessibility request time
Data readinessMeasures the reduction in manual effort for data teams.
Target: Reduce from days to hours in 6 months.
Roadmap
Your 90-day plan
Sequenced to fix the weakest foundations first.
Days 0 to 30
Stabilise
- Establish AI steering committee.
- Create and publish AI acceptable use policy.
- Audit all active AI pilots and identify high-value candidates.
- Commence process documentation for the top three operational workflows.
Days 31 to 60
Build
- Train process owners on process mapping standards.
- Implement a standard business case template for all future AI projects.
- Launch internal AI communication strategy to address staff concerns.
- Define success KPIs for the remaining active AI pilots.
Days 61 to 90
Embed
- Develop explainability documentation for existing high-priority AI models.
- Formalise the AI pilot to production transition pipeline.
- Introduce automated data quality checks at source.
- Launch formal AI training path for operations staff.
For leadership
Questions your leadership team must answer
- 01Are we prepared to stop all current AI experiments that lack a clear, documented business case?
- 02Do our current back-office processes provide a stable enough foundation to be amplified by AI?
- 03How can we explain to our customers and regulators exactly why an AI-driven insurance decision was made?
- 04Are our business managers willing to take full ownership of the AI tools used in their functions?
- 05What specific business outcomes, rather than 'efficiency', are we aiming to achieve with this AI investment?
Next steps
How Lean 6 Sigma Hub can help
The services that best fit the gaps in your results.
Want to talk through your results?
Book a free discovery conversation. We will walk through your report and agree the best next step.
This report is generated from your own answers with the help of AI. It is a starting point for discussion, not a formal audit or professional advice.
