Skip to content
Lean 6 Sigma Hub logo

This is a sample report for a fictional organisation (Fictional regional bank). Your report is written from your own answers.

Take the assessment

Lean Six Sigma Programme Health Check

Sample report: Lean Six Sigma Programme Health Check

Completed 21 November 2026

37
out of 100

Overall score

Emerging

Your Lean Six Sigma programme is currently an expensive hobby for belts that fails to deliver credible financial impact, requiring immediate pivot from ad-hoc projects to business-integrated value delivery.

Early stage 0 to 24Emerging 25 to 49Developing 50 to 74Advanced 75 to 100
Strongest area
Sponsorship and governance
Weakest area
Benefits and financial validation
High-likelihood risks
3

Scorecard

Your score by area

Each area is scored from your answers. A weakness in one area holds back the others.

01Sponsorship and governance
50% · Developing
02Project selection and pipeline
33% · Emerging
03Belt capability and roles
33% · Emerging
04Method and project quality
50% · Developing
05Benefits and financial validation
25% · Emerging
06Sustainment and culture
33% · Emerging

Red flags

Answers that need urgent attention (3)

These answers sit at the weakest level.

Project selection and pipeline
Is there a healthy pipeline of future projects?
“There is no pipeline”
Belt capability and roles
How much time do belts get for projects?
“None; projects sit on top of the day job”
Benefits and financial validation
Are benefits tracked after the project closes?
“No”

Executive summary

What this means for your organisation

The programme is stagnating at a 37% health score, functioning more as a training initiative than a strategic business lever. While formal structures like steering groups exist, the lack of active executive sponsorship and absence of dedicated capacity for practitioners means the organisation is not capitalising on its existing investment in belts. The current operation produces sporadic results that are disconnected from the bank's core business planning and financial targets.

The core diagnosis is a lack of rigorous, enterprise-wide integration. The absence of a project pipeline means that improvement efforts are reactive rather than proactive, and the lack of independent benefits validation undermines the credibility of the entire initiative with senior management. Because Belts treat projects as an additional burden to their day jobs, progress is slow and the sustainment of improvements is left to chance rather than robust control systems.

To rescue this programme, the bank must first link the improvement agenda to the annual budget and resource allocation. Immediate steps must be taken to formalise benefits validation, transition from a 'belt-led hobby' to a 'business-owned transformation' model, and secure dedicated capacity for top-tier practitioners. Without these changes, the programme will continue to generate local optimisations that fail to move the firm's bottom-line performance.

Key strengths

  • Presence of a steering group with established terms of reference
  • Formalised project governance through defined tollgates
  • Effective foundational training that incorporates live project requirements
  • Clear role definitions for the programme infrastructure

Risk register

Critical risks

Ranked by severity, with the business consequence and the recommended mitigation.

01
HighSponsorship and governance

Total loss of executive sponsorship and business alignment

Impact

Programme defunding and loss of organisational mandate

Mitigation

Establish a mandatory quarterly review where sponsors must report on value delivered by their specific projects

02
HighBenefits and financial validation

Financial credibility deficit due to self-reported benefits

Impact

Loss of trust from the Finance department and leadership

Mitigation

Appoint a finance business partner to act as an independent validator for all project savings

03
HighBelt capability and roles

Burnout and attrition of skilled practitioners

Impact

Loss of institutional knowledge and ability to execute complex improvements

Mitigation

Negotiate a minimum 20 percent time allocation for Black Belts with their line managers

04
MediumSustainment and culture

Sustainability failure leading to process regression

Impact

Reversal of gains and waste of previous transformation effort

Mitigation

Integrate control plan compliance into existing operational audit schedules

Dependencies

How the areas affect each other

  • The lack of a project pipeline is directly caused by the absence of active sponsorship, as leaders are not identifying the business problems that need solving.
  • Without independent benefits validation, the programme cannot secure the resource allocation required to solve the capacity issue for belts.
  • The 'belt-only' culture is a symptom of poor communication from leadership; when the business does not own the project, it remains a peripheral activity for the belt.

Benchmark

Maturity benchmark

Maturity for each area on a five-level scale, compared with typical organisations.

Sponsorship and governance

Level 2, Emerging. In typical regional banks, sponsors are actively involved in tollgate reviews rather than just attending steering meetings.

Project selection and pipeline

Level 1, Ad hoc. Successful banks maintain a rolling pipeline of 12-18 months of projects aligned to strategic cost-reduction targets.

Belt capability and roles

Level 1, Ad hoc. Top-tier organisations require 50 to 100 percent of a Black Belt's time to be dedicated to improvement work.

Method and project quality

Level 3, Defined. Most banks operate at this level, but they often struggle with the transition from data collection to rigorous root cause verification.

Benefits and financial validation

Level 1, Ad hoc. Financial validation must involve Finance as a gatekeeper to ensure that project benefits translate to actual budget or capacity releases.

Sustainment and culture

Level 2, Emerging. Mature organisations treat CI as part of the daily management system, not as a project-based intervention.

Momentum

Quick wins

Actions you can take in the next two to four weeks.

Implement a mandatory finance sign-off on all project charters

Improvement Lead · 2 weeks

Increased credibility of reported project savings

Audit current projects and terminate those without clear link to business goals

Steering Group · 3 weeks

Free up capacity for high-value strategic work

Publish a list of 'Stalled Projects' to force sponsorship intervention

Improvement Lead · 4 weeks

Increased visibility of roadblocks and resource constraints

Standardise the project documentation repository

Programme Manager · 4 weeks

Improved knowledge sharing and easier project handover

Diagnosis

Area-by-area diagnosis

01Sponsorship and governance

50%Level 2 · Emerging

The governance framework is technically present but functionally inert. While the steering group meets, the absence of active senior leadership turns these meetings into reporting sessions rather than decision-making forums. The programme operates in a silo, disconnected from the broader business strategy and resource planning cycle. This structural weakness prevents the programme from addressing enterprise-level pain points.

Root causes

  • • Inadequate definition of 'active sponsorship'
  • • Poor alignment between CI and the annual budget cycle

Evidence from your answers

“A senior leader is named but rarely involved”
“It is mentioned in plans but not resourced”
What good looks like: Sponsors define the problem, remove barriers to project success and hold process owners accountable for sustaining gains.

Strengths

  • • Formal steering group meeting cadence
  • • Clear definition of programme roles

Gaps

  • • Lack of executive engagement in project outcomes
  • • No resourcing tied to the improvement plan

Actions

  • • Re-contract sponsors on their specific accountability for project outcomes
  • • Embed CI targets into the senior leadership performance scorecards
  • • Integrate project demand into the annual budgeting cycle

02Project selection and pipeline

33%Level 1 · Ad hoc

The programme lacks a deliberate strategy for selection, resulting in opportunistic rather than value-driven work. There is no active pipeline, which means belts often search for problems rather than solving the most urgent business issues. Projects are often scoped well individually, but they fail to cumulatively impact the bank's bottom line because they are not prioritised strategically.

Root causes

  • • Absence of a strategic alignment framework for project selection
  • • Lack of senior management input into the priority list

Evidence from your answers

“From a list, with little screening”
“There is no pipeline”
What good looks like: A tiered pipeline of strategic and operational projects that is refreshed quarterly and prioritised by executive leadership.

Strengths

  • • Clear project charter format

Gaps

  • • No proactive pipeline management
  • • Low-rigour screening process for incoming projects

Actions

  • • Establish a quarterly project prioritisation session with senior leadership
  • • Develop a strategic alignment matrix to score project proposals
  • • Create a visual pipeline dashboard to track project health and timing

03Belt capability and roles

33%Level 1 · Ad hoc

Practitioners are currently set up to fail. Requiring belts to balance transformation work on top of a full-time job ensures that projects will always be slow and quality will suffer. The lack of formal, protected time indicates that the organisation views Lean Six Sigma as a secondary skill rather than a primary vehicle for transformation.

Root causes

  • • Line management pressure to prioritise core operational tasks over improvement
  • • Lack of clear career pathing for certified practitioners

Evidence from your answers

“None; projects sit on top of the day job”
“Informal help from colleagues”
What good looks like: Belts are deployed as internal consultants with protected capacity and formal coaching support from a Master Black Belt.

Strengths

  • • Training includes practical application on live projects

Gaps

  • • No dedicated project time
  • • Weak support system for belt development post-certification

Actions

  • • Define and enforce minimum time allocations for belts based on certification level
  • • Formalise a coaching rhythm between senior belts and practitioners
  • • Link project success to professional development goals for belts

04Method and project quality

50%Level 3 · Defined

The method is correctly taught and applied, but the rigour is often lost in execution. Projects follow the DMAIC structure, yet they often fail to move beyond data observation into verifiable root cause analysis. While tollgates are formal, they appear to be a check-box exercise rather than a meaningful barrier to poor-quality work.

Root causes

  • • Over-reliance on qualitative observations rather than statistical verification
  • • Fragmented documentation hindering peer review

Evidence from your answers

“On most projects”
“With some data, but rarely verified”
“Each belt keeps it in their own files”
What good looks like: A centralised digital platform where all project tollgates, data analysis, and verification evidence are transparent and accessible.

Strengths

  • • Consistency in tollgate execution
  • • General adherence to the DMAIC framework

Gaps

  • • Lack of formalised root cause verification
  • • Decentralised project documentation

Actions

  • • Mandate statistical verification of root causes in the 'Analyse' phase
  • • Implement a shared project management and document repository
  • • Introduce a 'peer review' step before formal tollgate meetings

05Benefits and financial validation

25%Level 1 · Ad hoc

This is the most critical failure point in the programme. When belts report their own benefits without external validation, the credibility of the entire programme is compromised. The failure to track results post-project means that the organisation is unable to confirm if the gains are real or if they have dissipated after closure.

Root causes

  • • Lack of collaboration between the improvement office and Finance
  • • Absence of a standardised benefits tracking tool

Evidence from your answers

“With rough guesses at the start”
“The belt reports their own benefits”
“No”
What good looks like: Benefits are pre-validated by Finance at the charter stage and post-validated through actual budget/headcount impact reporting.

Strengths

  • • None
  • • Occasional success stories used for visibility

Gaps

  • • Self-reported benefits bias
  • • Zero post-closure benefit tracking

Actions

  • • Create a finance-approved benefit calculation template
  • • Require a sign-off from the budget holder for all claimed benefits
  • • Establish a post-project review process at 3, 6, and 12 months

06Sustainment and culture

33%Level 2 · Emerging

The programme is perceived as a niche activity for specialists, which limits its cultural impact. Improvements are not locked into the management system, leading to a high rate of regression. Because the programme has not evolved in years, it is viewed as stagnant rather than a dynamic source of innovation for the bank.

Root causes

  • • Lack of engagement with operational leaders to integrate control plans into business-as-usual
  • • Failure to communicate success beyond project completion

Evidence from your answers

“As something only belts do”
“It runs, but has not changed in years”
What good looks like: Standard work and control plans are audited by line managers as part of daily operational management.

Strengths

  • • Occasional reuse of solutions through informal networks

Gaps

  • • Weak sustainment mechanisms
  • • Lack of programme evolution

Actions

  • • Build standard work audit routines for process owners
  • • Develop an annual programme improvement roadmap
  • • Create a 'Community of Practice' to share solutions formally

Measures

KPIs to track

Measures that show whether things are improving.

Realised financial savings vs. initial estimates

Benefits and financial validation

Determines the accuracy of project forecasting and budget impact.

Target: Within 10% of forecast by end of next quarter

Percentage of projects with Finance-validated benefits

Benefits and financial validation

Restores the credibility of the programme with leadership.

Target: 100% within 2 months

Belt utilisation rate (hours on projects vs. BAU)

Belt capability and roles

Tracks whether belts are being given the time to succeed.

Target: 20% minimum

Project cycle time variance

Method and project quality

Indicates whether projects are being adequately resourced and managed.

Target: Reduction by 20% in 90 days

Percentage of projects sustaining gains at 6 months

Sustainment and culture

Proves the efficacy of control plans.

Target: 80% success rate

Roadmap

Your 90-day plan

Sequenced to fix the weakest foundations first.

Days 0 to 30

Stabilise

  • Finalise finance-approved benefit calculation templates.
  • Audit all active projects for strategic alignment and kill non-performers.
  • Formally brief sponsors on their required accountability levels.
  • Establish a central digital documentation repository.

Days 31 to 60

Build

  • Implement the 20% capacity rule for Black Belts with line managers.
  • Roll out the new Finance-led validation process for all project charters.
  • Launch a quarterly pipeline review session with the leadership team.

Days 61 to 90

Embed

  • Conduct post-project audits on completed work from the last 12 months.
  • Integrate control plan audits into line management standard work.
  • Launch the CI Community of Practice for formal knowledge sharing.

For leadership

Questions your leadership team must answer

  1. 01Are you prepared to link project outcomes to your own performance bonus?
  2. 02Will you hold your direct reports accountable for participating in improvement projects?
  3. 03Are you willing to release capacity from your team for these projects, or is this just another 'off-the-side-of-the-desk' activity?
  4. 04How will you measure the success of this programme in terms of profit or efficiency rather than just the number of belts trained?
  5. 05What specific business problem will this programme solve for you in the next quarter?

Next steps

How Lean 6 Sigma Hub can help

The services that best fit the gaps in your results.

Want to talk through your results?

Book a free discovery conversation. We will walk through your report and agree the best next step.

Book a discovery conversation

This report is generated from your own answers with the help of AI. It is a starting point for discussion, not a formal audit or professional advice.